MVAR::subset() copied the source valueRecordSize into the output
header but then walked the source array with a typed
VariationValueRecord pointer (8-byte stride) and embedded 8 bytes per
record. For a font whose MVAR uses value records longer than 8 bytes
(valueRecordSize > 8, which the spec and MVAR::sanitize() allow), every
record after the first was read from the wrong offset and the emitted
header described a record array that overlaps the table's own
ItemVariationStore, silently losing metric variations on partial
instancing.
Step through the source records with StructAtOffset at the table's own
valueRecordSize stride, the same way sanitize() and get_var() do, and
declare VariationValueRecord::static_size in the emitted header so it
always matches the 8-byte records that are written. Output for the
usual 8-byte fonts is byte-identical.
Adds a subset regression test (mvar_partial_instance_record_size) built
from NotoSans-VF.abc with its MVAR records re-padded to 12 bytes; its
expected instanced output is byte-identical to the 8-byte
mvar_partial_instance wght=300:600 file and it fails on the unpatched
tree.
Reported by Anthropic's OSS Scanner as ordinary bug ANT-2026-EJUT4BZL.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Matching lookup lists alone cannot establish that same-tag features are
duplicates. Different feature parameters carry distinct UI metadata, and
alternate features can have different behavior in each language system.
Compare complete supported parameter data before merging, and preserve
indices referenced by retained feature variations. Fully pinned fonts can
still merge features after resolving their alternates.
Add GSUB/GPOS regressions with differing cv01 character arrays, size
values, ss01 names, and ss02 alternatives, plus identical ss03 controls.
The full Meson suite passes, as do reduced-feature compilation checks.
Assisted-by: Codex
Alternate feature serialization lacks the source feature tag, so it
cannot identify and retain cvXX, ssXX, or size parameters. Name-ID
closure also visits only the original base feature, losing labels
referenced by retained alternates or fully instantiated substitutions.
Carry source tags for retained features after deduplication. Collect
name IDs from the current base feature, retained variation records,
and original features used by catch-all records.
Add ordinary, full, partial, and range regressions for all three
parameter formats in GSUB and GPOS. Ten of twelve regression subtests
fail before the fix. The complete Meson suite passes: 284 tests.
The changed layout units also compile with HB_NO_VAR.
Assisted-by: Codex
The IUP optimizer returns success for contours larger than its 512-bit
sets can represent, leaving every optimized reference false. The
resulting partial instance loses the contour's variation data.
Keep all explicit references when skipping optimization at that limit.
This preserves the existing bounded search without changing geometry.
Add a 600-point contour regression. The original subsetter fails both
normal and preprocessed checks. The entire configured Meson suite
passes (278 tests, one skipped).
Assisted-by: Codex
Variation deltas can take solid and gradient stop alpha outside [0, 1].
Narrowing those values to F2DOT14 before clamping wraps alpha 2 to -2
and alpha -3 to 1, reversing the intended opacity.
Clamp full instances in float before storing alpha. Keep partial bases
unclamped because surviving axes can bring them back into range.
Add synthetic solid and gradient regressions for overflow, underflow,
and a partial base of 1.5 reduced to 0.5 by the retained axis. The old
subsetter fails four full-instance checks; the entire configured Meson
suite passes (278 tests, one skipped).
Assisted-by: Codex
serialize_rangeoffset_glyid() treated every zero idDelta as "this
range needs a glyphIdArray", which is what to_ranges() emits for
non-run ranges. A real run with delta 0 (glyph id == codepoint) got
the same treatment and cost two bytes per codepoint.
Only zero deltas are ambiguous. Check those against the mapping and
keep the ones that are genuinely identity as delta ranges.
Adds a subset test with a small hand-built glyf font whose cmap maps
U+0001..U+0007 to gids 1..7.
Tested with: meson test -C build
Assisted-by: opencode
* [subset] Fix empty ClassDefFormat2 not intersecting class zero
An empty ClassDef (rangeCount == 0) assigns class zero to every glyph, but
ClassDefFormat2::intersects_class() and intersected_classes() reported no
intersection when glyphs is not empty.
Adds a subset test that fails before and passes after.
* [subset] Fix empty ClassDefFormat1 not intersecting class zero
Same bug as the previous commit, in the format 1 variant. When glyphCount is
zero and startGlyphID is zero, `startGlyph + classValue.len - 1` underflows
to 0xFFFFFFFF, so neither of the two comparisons can be true and class zero
is never reported. (With a nonzero startGlyphID it happens to work.)
harfbuzz always serializes an empty ClassDef as format 2, so this is only
reachable with fonts produced by other tools.
Extends the previous test with a hand-built format 1 variant of the font.
An avar version 2 table with a NULL varStore offset is legal and maps
like plain v1 — but partial-instancing it used to fail outright, because
the planner errored against the missing store. Rather than falling back
to the v1 instancing path (which rescales every variation store and is
not always bit-exact), keep such fonts on the avar2 path: mapping
entries that don't resolve to a real store row are normalized to
NO_VARIATIONS_INDEX, mirroring runtime get_delta semantics, and offset
compensation creates the needed delta rows on demand in an empty store.
The instance stays version 2 and bit-exact, and consumers that ignore
the v2 tail still see the renormalized v1 segment maps.
Adds a subset test with a null-VarStore variant of the RobotoDelta test
font; the instancing test fails outright without the fix.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
* [instancer] Don't dedup VarStore rows when not optimizing
as_item_varstore dropped duplicate delta rows even with optimize=false,
where varidx_map is left empty and callers rely on original
VariationIndex values staying valid. HVAR/VVAR subsetting uses that
mode when the source table has an implicit (map-less) advance mapping:
any two glyphs sharing identical deltas shifted every following row, so
the synthesized identity map pointed at wrong rows and past the end of
the VarData — advances silently froze or took neighbors' deltas when
partially instancing such fonts (e.g. Source Han fonts).
Fixes https://github.com/harfbuzz/harfbuzz/issues/6068
* [subset] Drop identity advance maps for map-less HVAR/VVAR sources
When the source table uses implicit glyph-id indexing, the subsetter
synthesized an advance DeltaSetIndexMap whose content was the identity
over every output glyph — equivalent to the implicit indexing it
replaced, just bigger. Recognize that case in is_identity () and keep
the output map-less, like fontTools does. Sources that carry a real
map keep one, preserving their form; truncated maps don't qualify since
glyphs past their end share the last value.
retain-num-glyphs expected files regenerated: NotoSansJP-VF.subset.otf
is map-less, and its redundant identity map is now dropped (verified
against fontTools output).
* [test/subset] Test partial instancing of map-less HVAR
ImplicitHVAR.ttf carries an HVAR with implicit (map-less) advance
indexing and deliberately duplicated delta rows, the combination that
broke before the row-dedup fix: rows shifted or fell off the end of the
rebuilt VarData and advances silently froze. Expected outputs are
cross-checked against fontTools varLib.instancer + subset.
* [subset-repack] fix potential out of bounds accesses
make sure we create a deep copy of the object before we mutate
* [subset-repack] fix is_shared(): only check real parents
* [subset-repack] add tests
* [subset-repack] apply AI proposed change
* address review comments
* [subset-repack] no need to duplicate shared liga_sets beforehand
Since we now would create a memory copy of the object before mutating
it, I think checking and duplicating shared liga_sets is not needed.
* [subset-repack] fix potential out of bounds accesses
make sure we create a deep copy of the object before we mutate
* [subset-repack] fix is_shared(): only check real parents
* [subset-repack] add tests
* [subset-repack] apply AI proposed change
* address review comments
* [subset-repack] no need to duplicate shared liga_sets beforehand
Since we now would create a memory copy of the object before mutating
it, I think checking and duplicating shared liga_sets is not needed.
Add AdobeVFPrototype_vsindex.otf (already used by test/api): two
VarData subtables with distinct region sets and a charstring-level
vsindex, covering VarData pruning/renumbering, vsindex remapping and
the re-emitted charstring prefix.
Update Muli and Roboto input test fonts to recalc class values. FontTools recalcs class values during instancing while harfbuzz does not (like the ft subsetter).
also increase the HB_GLYF_MAX_POINTS limit to 20000 cause the test file has a
.notdef glyph which is a composite glyph and has 10176 points after
get_points() call
Also updated the script that is used to generate tests.With fonttools,
we now do instancing first and then subsetting.
With different order of subsetting and instancing operations on the same
VF file, fonttools seems to generate 2 different font files with different
glyph set.
1. do subsetting and then instancing: this seems result in a larger glyph
set in the font file. Lookups are collected from both retained features
and all possible alternate featurevariations, this leads to a larger
glyph set after glyph closurei. And instancer doesn't redo glyph
closure, it does lookups pruning only.
2. do instancing and then subsetting: lookups are collected from
features that are replaced already and possible alternate feature
variations
The existing code doesn't correctly handle the case where palettes partially overlap in the color record array. This changes the subsetting to only share entries in the color record array when palettes have the same first color index. Partially overlapping palettes will be converted to disjoint segments in the color record array.
Updates one of the color tests to use multiple palettes.
Also fixes fuzzer: https://oss-fuzz.com/testcase-detail/5568200165687296.