- Item attribute 0x10837 is the drop shadow EffectColor, written by the object style comparison of the other transparency values. Where the style stores no swatch, Black is left out: one item has it, and its IDML has no EffectColor. - ColumnRuleOverride is the u32 at 0 of chunk 0x22646 and is written as true or false. compare.py --exclude own/, trustworthy pairs: DropShadowSetting EffectColor 0 -> 11/11, TextFramePreference ColumnRuleOverride 21,165 -> 21,167/21,167, 4 more Color elements (swatches the shadows use). No new extra values; no pair loses values.
12 KiB
Transparency
Implemented in src/idml/transparency.rs.
Page items keep their transparency settings in their attribute list
(chunk 0x6E03, see attributes.md), with attribute IDs in two ranges:
0x108xx and 0x1EBxx. Object styles keep a full list of the same
attributes in chunk 0x1B92C (u16 count, then records).
IDML writes them as child elements of the page item: TransparencySetting
(the whole object), StrokeTransparencySetting and
FillTransparencySetting, each holding one element per effect
(BlendingSetting, DropShadowSetting, InnerShadowSetting,
GradientFeatherSetting, ...).
How the mapping was checked
IDML writes a setting on a page item only when it differs from the item's object style. So each INDD value was compared with the value in effect:
- the value written on the IDML item, if there is one;
- otherwise the value of its object style, following
BasedOn; - otherwise the default in
Resources/Preferences.xml(TransparencyDefaultContainerObject).
The tables count page items of the pairs whose IDML is from the same InDesign version as the INDD. "On the item" means the IDML item states the value itself, which is the evidence that tells the attribute apart. The 576 object styles of the pairs (matched by name) agree with their IDML style on every attribute below.
Values equal to the object style
The converter writes only the values that differ from the object
style's (its chunk 0x1B92C, then the styles it is based on), and an
effect element only when it has such a value or its opacity stops
differ from the style's. Per effect element the converter wrote before
this rule, over the 489 trustworthy pairs (D = the attributes whose value
differs from the style's effective value; style values followed through
BasedOn, then TransparencyDefaultContainerObject):
| Element | D empty, IDML writes nothing | D empty, IDML writes it | D not empty, IDML writes exactly D or more |
|---|---|---|---|
GradientFeatherSetting |
6,251 | 53 | 2,604 |
InnerShadowSetting |
2,884 | 0 | 17 |
DropShadowSetting |
44 | 8 | 289 |
BlendingSetting |
1 | 0 | 1,616 |
Where IDML writes more than D (349 elements), the converter already wrote those values. The 53 + 8 elements with D empty that IDML still writes are not explained.
Object transparency (TransparencySetting)
The drop shadow rows of 0x1081B, 0x1081C, 0x1081E, 0x1081F and 0x1084A
come from the items of the 1,251 trustworthy pairs of the corpus after
2026-10 that have a DropShadowSetting in IDML, groups included: each
ID is the only one whose value equals the IDML value in every item
where both exist (after resolving the value through the object style,
as below). In the item list 0x1081F is the drop shadow's blend mode; in
the document preference list the same number is BlendingSpace, a
separate list. With the write rule below, the converter reproduces over
the trustworthy pairs 580 of 580 XOffset and YOffset values, 397 of
397 Opacity, 62 of 62 BlendMode and 3 of 3 Spread, with no extra
value.
Comparison with the style. IDML writes an item's value when it
differs from the style's in any digit: one 15.0 document has 23 text
frames with YOffset 7.000000133081193 and a style value of 7, and
IDML writes all 23. Comparing the full text of the values changes
nothing else in the transparency settings of the trustworthy pairs.
| ID | IDML | Encoding | On the item |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0x10816 | BlendingSetting/Opacity |
f64, percent | 57 items in 4 files (40, 49, 50, 57, 69, 70) |
| 0x10817 | BlendingSetting/BlendMode |
i32 code (below) | 56 items in 4 files |
| 0x1081A | DropShadowSetting/Mode |
i32: 0 None, 1 Drop |
8 items with 1 in 2 files |
| 0x1081F | DropShadowSetting/BlendMode |
i32 code (below): 0 Normal, 4 SoftLight seen |
89 of 89 items in 16 files |
| 0x1081E | DropShadowSetting/Opacity |
f64, percent | 424 of 424 items in 78 files |
| 0x1081B | DropShadowSetting/XOffset |
f64 | 649 of 649 items in 88 files |
| 0x1081C | DropShadowSetting/YOffset |
f64 | 649 of 649; 256 of these items have X ≠ Y |
| 0x10820 | DropShadowSetting/Size |
f64 | 6 items, two values; 406 of 406 rectangles and text frames over the 654 pairs of the later corpus |
| 0x1084A | DropShadowSetting/Spread |
f64, percent | 28 of 28 items in 9 files |
| 0x10837 | DropShadowSetting/EffectColor |
swatch UID | 11 of 11 items in 6 files (below) |
| 0x1084D | InnerShadowSetting/Applied |
u16: 1 true, 0 false | 10 items with 1 |
| 0x1084E | InnerShadowSetting/EffectColor |
swatch UID | 10 items (below) |
| 0x10852 | InnerShadowSetting/Distance |
f64 | 10 items with 0 |
| 0x10855 | InnerShadowSetting/Size |
f64 | 10 items with 2.83 |
| 0x1EB8A | GradientFeatherSetting/Applied |
u16: 1 true, 0 false | 56 items in 2 files |
| 0x1EB8C | GradientFeatherSetting stops |
list (below) | 59 items, 170 stops |
| 0x1EB8D | GradientFeatherSetting/Angle |
f64 | 1 item (−90) |
| 0x1EB8E | GradientFeatherSetting/Length |
f64 | 96 items in 3 files |
| 0x1EB8F | GradientFeatherSetting/GradientStart |
two f64 | 96 items in 3 files |
| 0x1EB91 | GradientFeatherSetting/HiliteAngle |
f64 | 1 item (−62.2) |
| 0x1EB92 | GradientFeatherSetting/HiliteLength |
f64 | 1 item (1) |
More IDs, found over the 489 trustworthy pairs before 2026-10 by
matching the item's attribute list with the IDML value after resolving
the value through the object style, BasedOn and
TransparencyDefaultContainerObject (each ID is the only one whose
value maps one to one onto the IDML value in all rows):
| ID | IDML | Encoding | Items |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0x10819 | BlendingSetting/IsolateBlending |
u16: 1 true | 46 of 46 |
| 0x10857 | OuterGlowSetting/Applied |
u16: 1 true | 157 of 157 |
| 0x10858 | OuterGlowSetting/BlendMode |
i32 code (below; 0, 1, 3, 9 seen) | 79 of 79 |
| 0x10859 | OuterGlowSetting/Opacity |
f64 | 144 of 144 |
| 0x1085B | OuterGlowSetting/EffectColor |
swatch UID | 73 of 73 |
| 0x1085D | OuterGlowSetting/Spread |
f64 | 106 of 106 |
| 0x1085E | OuterGlowSetting/Size |
f64 | 172 of 172 |
| 0x1085F | InnerGlowSetting/Applied |
u16 | 6 of 6 |
| 0x10860 | InnerGlowSetting/BlendMode |
i32 code (0, 1 seen) | 10 of 10 |
| 0x10866 | InnerGlowSetting/Size |
f64 | 10 of 10 |
| 0x108D8 | FillTransparencySetting/BlendingSetting/Opacity |
f64 | 6 of 6 (100, 40) |
IDML writes OuterGlowSetting and InnerGlowSetting after
InnerShadowSetting, as the schema lists them. Not identified: the
inner glow's Opacity, Spread and EffectColor, the outer glow's
Noise, and drop shadow KnockedOut (497 items of one 8.0 document,
true in all, no local ID varies).
All items whose value is not on the IDML item (it comes from the style
or the default) match as well: for example 743 items for
InnerShadowSetting and the gradient feather attributes, with the
default values (Applied="false", Distance="7", Size="7", Length="0").
In pairs whose IDML is from an older version, 14 more items match on opacity and blend mode. One item there has 50 where the IDML says 100; that file was probably saved again after the export.
Values outside the schema's range. Four items in a file without an IDML store a drop shadow size of −2.83; the schema allows 0 to 1000. The converter leaves out any value of the attributes above that is outside the schema's range, with a warning: sizes and distances 0–1000, opacity 0–100, angles −180–180.
Blend mode codes. The code is the position of the value in the IDML
schema's BlendMode enumeration (Normal, Multiply, Screen,
Overlay, SoftLight, HardLight, ColorDodge, ColorBurn,
Darken, Lighten, Difference, Exclusion, Hue, Saturation,
Color, Luminosity, from 0). Seen: 1 Multiply (3 items), 3
Overlay (62), 9 Lighten (5), and 0 Normal in all 576 object
styles, whose IDML blend mode is Normal; over the 489 trustworthy
pairs before 2026-10 also 2
Screen (7 items), 4 SoftLight (10), 5 HardLight (12), 7
ColorBurn (3), 14 Color (3) and 15 Luminosity (7), 42 of 42. The
converter writes all sixteen positions.
Inner shadow colour. The 10 items with the effect applied name the
swatch that IDML writes as EffectColor. Items without the effect store
UID 0xB, where the IDML default is n (no colour). The converter writes
the colour only when the effect is applied.
Drop shadow colour. Item attribute 0x10837 is the swatch of the
drop shadow, IDML EffectColor. With the write rule above, the
converter reproduces all 11 EffectColor values of the trustworthy
pairs (8 polygons, 2 rectangles, 1 text frame; swatches such as
Color/Paper and named colours), with no extra value. In 7 of these
items the object style chain stores 0 for the attribute, which names no
swatch, so every item colour differs from it. The one other item whose
style stores 0 has the Black swatch, and its IDML has no
EffectColor. One item cannot show whether IDML compares with Black or
leaves the value out for another reason; the converter leaves out
Black when the style stores 0.
Not covered: items whose drop shadow is off (Mode="None") for which
IDML still writes a DropShadowSetting (the "D empty, IDML writes it"
column above).
Stroke and fill transparency
Only the gradient feather has values that tell its attributes apart:
| ID | IDML | On the item |
|---|---|---|
| 0x1EB93 | StrokeTransparencySetting/GradientFeatherSetting/Applied |
2 items through their style, and the style |
| 0x1EB95 | stroke gradient feather stops | 2 items |
| 0x1EB96 | StrokeTransparencySetting/GradientFeatherSetting/Angle |
2 items through their style (90), and the style |
| 0x1EB97 | StrokeTransparencySetting/GradientFeatherSetting/Length |
4 items in 2 files |
| 0x1EB98 | StrokeTransparencySetting/GradientFeatherSetting/GradientStart |
4 items in 2 files |
| 0x1EB9C | FillTransparencySetting/GradientFeatherSetting/Applied |
10 items, 1 through its style |
| 0x1EB9E | fill gradient feather stops | 11 items |
| 0x1EB9F | FillTransparencySetting/GradientFeatherSetting/Angle |
10 items (−90) |
| 0x1EBA0 | FillTransparencySetting/GradientFeatherSetting/Length |
3 items in 2 files |
| 0x1EBA1 | FillTransparencySetting/GradientFeatherSetting/GradientStart |
3 items in 2 files |
The stroke, fill and object gradient feathers of the same item can hold the same length and start, so each ID was taken from items where only one of the three is set (for example 0x1EB97 matches the stroke value in 4 items and the fill value in only 2).
Opacity gradient stops
Value type 0x1085F. A u32 stop count, then three f64 per stop:
| Field | Contents |
|---|---|
| f64 | Location, 0–1 (IDML Location in percent) |
| f64 | Position of the midpoint between this stop and the next, 0–1, measured from the start of the gradient; 1 for the last stop |
| f64 | Opacity in percent (IDML Opacity) |
IDML writes a Midpoint on every stop but the first: the midpoint
between the previous stop and this one, in percent of the distance
between them. So for stop i, Midpoint = (midpoint of stop i−1 −
location of stop i−1) / (location of stop i − location of stop i−1)
× 100. A list with count 0 is stored as a 4-byte value.
All 170 stops of the items above match on Opacity, Location and
Midpoint; so do the 5 stops of two object styles. IDML names an item's
stops <item>TransparencySetting1GradientFeatherSetting1OpacityGradientStop<i>
(with StrokeTransparencySetting or FillTransparencySetting for those
settings), 170 of 170.
Not converted
- Drop shadow
Noise,KnockedOutandUseGlobalLight. - Stroke, fill and content blending (opacity and blend mode) and the
other effects (feather, outer and inner glow, bevel and emboss, satin,
directional feather): no item or style in the pairs has a value other
than the default, so their attributes cannot be told apart. One text
frame has
ContentTransparencySettingwith an inner glow and a satin effect applied, and two attributes set to 1, so it cannot show which is which. GradientFeatherSetting/Type:Linearin every sample.- Transparency of placed graphics and object styles.