3.7 KiB
Gaps
The assessment below predates the 2026-11-05 primitive rewrite. Its old library counts and compatibility claims are historical. See atomic-workflow.md and ROADMAP.md for the current scope and remaining validation.
Current integration also provides workspace-scoped material_export, real Height displacement
from the assigned material, explicit normal-map convention, and linear bitmap/input previews.
The native SBS and primitive-library limitations in atomic-workflow.md remain.
Reusable SBS functions now appear in the Library for Function and processor canvases. The bundled library now retains all 171 supplied function bodies, with no empty implementation placeholders. Full numerical equivalence and importing the converted library in the reference application remain unverified. Redistribution rights for the retained source bodies are not established. See architecture.md for alias resolution and conversion details.
Explorer now displays native SBS folders, including empty groups and nested resources. Its initial package, folder and graph context menus support creation, copy/paste, rename, removal, and package save/reload/close actions. Publishing and additional resource creation menus remain outside this scope.
Last reviewed: 2026-11-02 · Last updated: 2026-11-02 · Change: minor (portable
.mcmatmaterials closed the published-archive gap) · Target: the professional node-based material workflow
Every known shortfall, most important first. Pick from the top.
| # | Gap | Evidence | Impact | Estimate | Parity doc |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Node library breadth | 227 nodes vs. ~400 in the reference library | Recipes that need scan processing, more grunges, splines or SDF shapes | 30 h | target-app-parity (Node library) |
| 2 | GPU 3D view with tessellation and lights | CPU renderer with parallax only | Displacement previews, light setups | 12 h | target-app-parity (3D view) |
| 3 | Mesh-based generators and bakers | None | Workflows that start from a mesh | 15 h | target-app-parity (Node library) |
| 4 | Portable materials over MCP | .mcmat export runs from the app and the CLI; the MCP workspace sandbox refuses file.* commands and has no material_export tool |
Sandboxed agents can't hand a material to TextureCraft | 1 h | target-app-parity (Files) |
| 5 | Function loops and reusable functions | Functions live on one parameter or processor | Iterative effects; sharing logic between nodes | 5 h | target-app-parity (Function graphs) |
| 6 | Input visibility conditions, per-instance output sizes | Not implemented | Organizing large graphs' inputs | 4 h | target-app-parity (Graph parameters) |
| 7 | ui.screenshot times out on this test machine |
The window-capture callback never fires here; view.screenshot and the offscreen snapshot test work |
Agents bridged to the app see views but not the whole window | 1 h | — |
| 8 | Translations and keymap editor | English only, fixed shortcuts | Non-English users; custom shortcuts | 8 h | localization-parity |
| 9 | Minimap and multi-graph tabs | One graph at a time, no overview | Navigating big graphs | 5 h | target-app-parity (Graph editing, UI and UX) |
| 10 | First signed release | Workflows copied, not run | Downloads | 3 h | target-app-parity (Platforms) |
Revision history
| Date | Change | Summary |
|---|---|---|
| 2026-11-02 | minor | Portable .mcmat materials for TextureCraft closed gap 4; what's left is an MCP tool |
| 2026-11-02 | major | Closed the function editor, dynamic parameters, FX-Map/Text/SVG, presets and groups, browser file I/O and accessible names; re-ranked |
| 2026-11-02 | major | First list |