Files

797 lines
41 KiB
Markdown
Raw Permalink Blame History

This file contains ambiguous Unicode characters
This file contains Unicode characters that might be confused with other characters. If you think that this is intentional, you can safely ignore this warning. Use the Escape button to reveal them.
# Values written from IDML observation
Some values the converter writes do not come from the INDD file. They are
values that every IDML exported by InDesign in the corpus has, on the
root styles and in the preferences. They are
facts about InDesign's IDML output, not about the INDD format, and the
evidence is the corpus IDML files alone. Values that nearly every IDML
has are listed under [Defaults](#defaults).
Why they are written: IDML consumers apply their own defaults to
attributes that are missing. When those defaults differ from InDesign's,
the layout differs. For example, a consumer that defaults to keeping all
lines of a paragraph together breaks pages differently from a document
whose root style says `KeepAllLinesTogether="false"`.
## Root style values
The root styles are `[No paragraph style]`, `[No character style]`, the
object style `[None]`, the cell style `[None]` and the table style
`[No table style]`. Every corpus IDML has all five.
`tools/root_values.py` reads `Resources/Styles.xml` of every corpus IDML
and collects each attribute of the root styles, each `Properties` child,
and each attribute of their child elements (for example
`TextFramePreference` in the object style). It keeps a value when:
- every IDML from some DOM version on has it, with the same value, and
- the converter does not read it from the INDD.
The kept values are in `src/idml/root_values.xml`, generated by that
tool. The converter writes them on its root styles. A value the
converter reads from the INDD takes precedence: for the paragraph and
character root styles, attributes in the text attribute table
(`attributes.md`) are left out of the file, and any attribute the INDD
supplies is written from the INDD.
The file is generated from the reference IDML of every pair that
`tools/compare.py` compares (a little-endian INDD whose IDML has the
same major version, without the privately held samples): 1,587 pairs,
1,450 distinct IDML files, DOM 7 to 21. Values that
first appear after DOM 7 are written only for documents of that
InDesign version or later (`MinimumVersion` in the file).
| Root style | Values | Same in | Written for version |
|---|---|---|---|
| `[No paragraph style]` | 1 | 1,450 of 1,450 files | all |
| | 3 | 1,333 of 1,333 files with DOM 10 or later | 10 and later |
| | 2 | 1,213 of 1,213 (DOM 11 or later) | 11 and later |
| | 5 | 1,041 of 1,041 (DOM 13 or later) | 13 and later |
| | 1 | 641 of 641 (DOM 15 or later) | 15 and later |
| | 1 | 62 of 62 (DOM 21) | 21 |
| `[No character style]` | 1 | 1,450 of 1,450 | all |
| | 2 | 1,213 of 1,213 (DOM 11 or later) | 11 and later |
| | 1 | 1,041 of 1,041 (DOM 13 or later) | 13 and later |
| | 1 | 641 of 641 (DOM 15 or later) | 15 and later |
| | 1 | 62 of 62 (DOM 21) | 21 |
| Object style `[None]` | 63 | 1,450 of 1,450 | all |
| | 9, 22, 1, 4, 7, 4, 4, 8 | all files with DOM 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15 or later | from that version |
| | 9 | 62 of 62 (DOM 21) | 21 |
| Cell style `[None]` | 1 | 1,450 of 1,450 | all |
| Table style `[No table style]` | 89 | 1,450 of 1,450 | all |
| | 6 | 1,211 of 1,211 (DOM 11 or later) | 11 and later |
| | 4 | 255 of 255 (DOM 18 or later) | 18 and later |
**Left out because they vary between files:**
- `[No paragraph style]` (19): `HyphenQuality`, `StyleUniqueId`, the
origins and some corner radii of paragraph borders and shading, and
the `StyleExportTagMap` child.
- `[No character style]`: `StyleUniqueId`.
- Object style `[None]` (42): among them `AppliedNamedGrid`,
`AppliedParagraphStyle`, `StrokeWeight`,
`BaselineFrameGridColor`, the corner radii, `OpticalMarginSize`,
`TextColumnGutter`, `FirstBaselineOffset`, the overprint settings,
the flexible layout paddings and gaps, and some export options.
- `[No table style]` (19): the border, row and column stroke weights,
`SpaceBefore`, `SpaceAfter`, the end stroke tints, the text insets,
`CaptionPosition`, `CaptionParagraphCount` and
`HeaderColumnCellStyle`. The four region cell styles
(`HeaderRegionCellStyle` and the others, `n`) are on every table root
style from DOM 18 only: 24 files of DOM 10 and 17 lack them.
The converter reads many of these from the INDD: the object style
settings (`objects.md`, object style settings and named grids), the
baseline frame grid colour (`preferences.md`), the attributes of the
root table style (`tables.md`), the paragraph border and shading
values (`attributes.md`), and the style unique IDs and export settings
(`objects.md`, styles).
Two kinds of IDML files are not evidence for the root styles, and the
pair rule leaves them out: an IDML (DOM 7) beside an INDD of version
17.2 that has no root styles at all, and a big-endian pair of version 11.2 whose table style lacks
four region cell style values that every other file has.
**Left out because the converter reads them from the INDD:** 299
attributes of `[No paragraph style]`, listed in `attributes.md`. Some
of these are also the same in every IDML; the INDD value is written.
The object styles other than `[None]` and the preferences (below) are
generated from the same pairs. Values that vary in any of them are left
out, even where one document is the exception: the converter writes
nothing for such a key unless it reads the value from the INDD.
The cell and table root styles are written as new elements in
`RootCellStyleGroup` and `RootTableStyleGroup`.
## Document attributes
`AccurateLABSpots="false"` is on the `Document` element of all 654
corpus pairs' IDML files. The converter writes it. The colour settings
next to it are read from the INDD (`preferences.md`).
`Name` (the package's file name) is on the `Document` element from DOM
13 only: 321 of 321 trustworthy references from DOM 13, 0 of 168 before.
From DOM 20.0 every `Document` element has `AppliedMathMLRgbColor="0 0
0"` and `TintValue="100"`, and a `Properties` child
`AppliedMathMLSwatch` (type `enumeration`) `Nothing`, after `Label`;
from DOM 20.4 also `PreferMathMLInEpubExport="false"` (all 99 and 72
distinct corpus IDML files of those versions; none before). The
converter writes them by the DOM version it writes, which the per-major
blocks cannot express for 20.4. `AppliedMathMLFontSize` is `10` in 96
of these files and `16` in 3 of DOM 20.2, with no field found; the
converter writes `10` as a default ([Defaults](#defaults)).
## Default numbering list
The root paragraph style refers to `NumberingList/$ID/[Default]`. Every
corpus IDML file has this element in `designmap.xml`, with the same
attributes: `Name="$ID/[Default]"`,
`ContinueNumbersAcrossStories="false"` and
`ContinueNumbersAcrossDocuments="false"`. The converter reads the
numbering lists from the INDD (`objects.md`, numbering lists) and writes
them after `idPkg:Styles`, where the IDML schema puts them. It writes
this default list with these values only for a file whose lists it
cannot read.
## Built-in stroke styles
All 240 corpus IDML files list the same 18 `StrokeStyle` elements in
`Resources/Graphic.xml`, in the same order, each with only `Self` and
`Name` (`StrokeStyle/$ID/Solid`, `$ID/Solid`, and so on). The converter
writes the same list, so every `StrokeType` it writes refers to an
element in the package.
## Story values
`tools/element_values.py` collects the values of `Story`, `XmlStory`
and their `StoryPreference` and `InCopyExportOption` children from the
1,495 corpus IDML files (`element_values.xml`); the converter writes them
where the INDD gives no value:
| Element | Values kept | Versions |
|---|---|---|
| `Story` | `TrackChanges="false"` | 7 on |
| `Story`, `XmlStory` | `UserText="true"` where written | 11 on; IDML has it from version 11.2 (none of the 3,184 stories of DOM 10.0 to 11.0, every story from 11.2), and the converter writes it from INDD version 11.2 |
| `InCopyExportOption` of stories | `IncludeGraphicProxies="true"`, `IncludeAllResources="false"` | 7 on |
From DOM 21.5 every `Story` and `XmlStory` also has
`AiGeneratedStory="false"`, `AiModelName="$ID/"`,
`AiDigitalSourceType="$ID/"`, `AiFirstParty="false"` and
`AiTextContent="$ID/"`, after `Self`: 62 of 62 stories and 4 of 4 XML
stories in the 4 corpus IDML files of DOM 21.5. No story of an earlier
DOM has them (694 stories and 58 XML stories of DOM 21.0 to 21.4, and
none of the earlier files). The value file is keyed by major version,
so the converter writes these values by the DOM version it writes (DOM
version, below).
The other story values are read from the INDD: `StoryTitle`,
`StoryDirection` and the optical margin from story chunks, with the
value of every story without the chunk when it is absent, and for the
optical margin size the value of the text size unit (`objects.md`,
story settings); `IsEndnoteStory` from the story class (`footnotes.md`);
`AppliedTOCStyle` from chunk 0x8C40.
`StoryPreference` `FrameType` and `StoryOrientation` are read from
story chunk 0x2EE (`objects.md`, story settings).
Left out because it varies: `Story` `AppliedNamedGrid` (106 of 27,816
stories name a grid, all in DOM 12 files). Before the corpus had
samples typeset in Japanese, every IDML had `n`.
## Graphic settings without an INDD field
`element_values.xml` holds the `ClippingPathSettings` values of every
`Image`, `PDF` and `EPS` element with `ClippingType="None"` in the 1,495
corpus IDML files:
`ClippingType="None"`, `InvertPath="false"`, `IncludeInsideEdges="false"`,
`RestrictToFrame="false"` and `AppliedPathName="$ID/"` (and for PDF and
EPS also the values the converter reads for images).
`tools/element_values.py` collects only the elements with `None`
(`WRITTEN_FOR`); the 12,280 such elements in the current corpus (8,993
images, 2,213 PDF, 1,074 EPS) have the values above. The converter
writes every attribute of the element from chunk 0x2C1A and the rules
in `objects.md` (clipping path settings), which give these values for
clipping type 0, and does not use these rows.
Every `ImageIOPreference` has `AllowAutoEmbedding="true"`. The
converter writes the values read from the INDD first (`objects.md`,
clipping path settings).
Over the 5,131 graphics of the trustworthy pairs, every graphic has
`LocalDisplaySetting="Default"`; every image (3,607)
`ImageRenderingIntent="UseColorSettings"`; every PDF and EPS (1,339)
`GrayVectorPolicy="IgnoreAll"`; every SVG (146) `UseSVGAs="EmbedCode"`.
From DOM 21 every image, PDF and SVG has `FlexItemWidthMode="FlexFixed"`
and `FlexItemHeightMode="FlexFixed"` (81 of 81), and SVG graphics from
21.2 have `IsMathMLObject="false"` (4 of 4). The constant values of
graphic layers are in `objects.md` (graphic layers). The converter
writes all of these.
## Links
These `Link` values are the same in all 4,699 links of the trustworthy
pairs, and the converter writes them on every link: `AssetURL="$ID/"`,
`AssetID="$ID/"`, `LinkClientID="257"` (the u32 at offset 4 of chunk 0x8C9B is 0x101 in
every link), `LinkObjectModified="false"`, `CanEmbed="true"`,
`CanUnembed="true"`, `CanPackage="true"`, `ImportPolicy="NoAutoImport"`
and `ExportPolicy="NoAutoExport"`. `LinkClassID` is the class of the
link object (`35906` for graphic links, `objects.md`, placed graphics).
`RenditionData="Actual"` is on every
link from DOM 13 on (3,043 of 3,043) and on none before (1,656 of
1,656); the converter writes it from version 13.
Every `Link` of DOM 21.5 has `AiGeneratedAsset="false"`,
`AiFullyGeneratedAsset="false"` and `AiC2paArchiveData="$ID/"`, after
`Self` (12 of 12 links in 3 IDML files; the fourth file of DOM 21.5 has
no link). Every `Link` of DOM 21.4 and 21.5 has `SourceObjectName=""`
(75 of 75 links in 11 files); no link of DOM 21.0 to 21.3 has it (170
links), nor does any link of an earlier DOM. No value varies, so no INDD
field is identified. The converter writes them by the DOM version it
writes.
## Anchored object settings of page items
Where IDML writes every anchored object setting of a page item (the ten
attributes `AnchoredPosition`, `SpineRelative`, `PinPosition`,
`AnchorPoint`, `HorizontalAlignment`, `HorizontalReferencePoint`,
`VerticalAlignment`, `VerticalReferencePoint`, `AnchorXoffset` and
`AnchorYoffset`; `objects.md`, anchored object settings), the element
also has `LockPosition="false"` and `AnchorSpaceAbove="0"`. This holds
for every item type and DOM version: 1,158 of 1,158 such elements in the
1,456 distinct IDML files of the corpus pairs (918 text frames, 142
ovals, 41 graphic lines, 32 polygons, 25 rectangles; DOM 8 to 21.2). No
element with fewer values has either attribute (633 of 633, including
all 125 group and 10 text box elements). No DOM 7 item has a complete
element; the preferences and object styles of DOM 7 have both
attributes. The converter adds the two values wherever it writes all ten
settings.
## Object styles other than the root
`tools/root_values.py` also collects the object styles other than
`[None]`: 4,961 styles in the 1,450 distinct IDML files, every file having
at least one. A value is kept when every such style of every IDML from some
DOM version on has it, with the same value, and at least 10 files show
it. The kept values are in `src/idml/object_style_values.xml`. The
converter writes them on every object style other than `[None]`, and
writes the values it reads from the INDD (`objects.md`, object style
settings) in their place.
| Values | Same in | Written for version |
|---|---|---|
| 49 | 1,450 of 1,450 files | all |
| 2, 22, 1, 5, 5, 4, 6, 11 | all files with DOM 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15 or later | from that version |
| 5, 3, 8 | 255, 158 and 94 files with DOM 18, 19, 20 or later | from that version |
| 41 | 62 of 62 files with DOM 21 | 21 |
Among them are the nine `Enable…` effect flags other than
`EnableTransparency` in the four `ObjectStyle…EffectsCategorySettings`
elements (all `true`), most of `ObjectExportOption`,
`TransformAttributeOption` from DOM 13, and
`UseFlexibleColumnWidth="false"` and `TextColumnMaxWidth="0"` of
`TextFramePreference` from DOM 8.
**Left out because they vary or are not in every style** (73): the
fill, stroke, line end, gap and corner values, the `Enable…` attributes,
`ApplyNextParagraphStyle`, `KeyboardShortcut`, `AnchoredObjectSetting`
`PinPosition`, `AnchorPoint`, `VerticalAlignment`, `SpineRelative` and
`HorizontalReferencePoint`, the frame fitting values, the story frame
type, orientation and direction, the text wrap mode, contour type and
`ApplyToMasterPageOnly`, the column, inset, footnote, auto-sizing and
column rule values of `TextFramePreference`, the baseline frame grid
values before DOM 18 and `EnableTransparency` before DOM 20. Most of
these vary in a few styles of a few documents. The converter reads many
of them from the INDD.
`TextFramePreference` `FootnotesEnableOverrides="false"` is on every
object style, `[None]` included, from InDesign 13.1: 1,392 of 1,392
styles of the trustworthy pairs before 2026-10, none before. The value
file has it only from DOM 14, since it is generated per major version;
the converter writes it when the header or the last session of the save
history is 13.1 or later (`objects.md`, save history).
## Inks
Every `Ink` element of the 1,495 corpus IDML files has `InkType="Normal"`
and `PrintInk="true"` (`element_values.xml`); the converter writes them
on every ink. `ConvertToProcess` is read from the INDD (`objects.md`,
inks).
## Values of other elements
`tools/element_values.py` collects the values of other elements the
converter writes from every distinct IDML of the corpus (1,495 files
exported by InDesign; IDML files that lack the `product` of InDesign's
`aid` processing instruction were written by a script, so they are left
out). A value is kept for a range of DOM versions when every
element of that kind in every file of those versions has it with the
same value, and it is left out entirely when some version shows two
values or elements without it. The values may differ between versions;
each range needs 10 files. The kept values are in
`src/idml/element_values.xml`, in blocks with `MinimumVersion` and
`MaximumVersion`. The converter writes them after the values it reads
from the INDD and only where the element lacks the attribute.
Files per DOM version: 7: 11, 8: 92, 9: 15, 10: 123, 11: 70, 12: 112,
13: 329, 14: 81, 15: 87, 16: 42, 17: 266, 18: 100, 19: 71, 20: 33, 21: 63.
### Page items
| Element | Elements | Values kept |
|---|---|---|
| `TextFrame` | 58,521 | `LocalDisplaySetting="Default"`, `GradientStrokeAngle`, `GradientStrokeHiliteLength`, `GradientStrokeHiliteAngle` (`0`) from DOM 7; `FlexItemWidthMode` and `FlexItemHeightMode` (`FlexFixed`) from 21 |
| `Rectangle` | 53,413 | `LocalDisplaySetting`, `StoryTitle="$ID/"` from 7 |
| `Oval` | 10,851 | `LocalDisplaySetting`, `StoryTitle` and the gradient highlights from 8 |
| `Polygon` | 134,377 | `LocalDisplaySetting`, `StoryTitle` and the fill gradient highlights from 7 |
| `GraphicLine` | 19,100 | `LocalDisplaySetting`, `LockState="None"` and the gradient highlights from 7 |
| `Group` | 15,857 | `LocalDisplaySetting` and the gradient highlights from 7 |
Each kind also has `FlexItemWidthMode` and `FlexItemHeightMode` from
DOM 21, and values that the converter reads from the INDD
(`objects.md`, page item settings), which take precedence. Values such
as `Name`, `Visible`, `Locked`, the gradient angles and the layout
constraints are not kept: they differ in some elements, and those
values come from the INDD.
### Form fields
`tools/element_values.py` also collects the form field elements
(`objects.md`, form fields). Only buttons and multi-state objects are in
enough files (282 buttons in 43 files, 18 multi-state objects in 16):
| Element | Values kept | Versions |
|---|---|---|
| `Button` | `VisibilityInPdf="VisibleInPdf"`, `HiddenUntilTriggered="false"` and the page item values below | DOM 8 to 18 (42 files) |
| `Button` | `PrintableInPdf="true"` | DOM 10 to 18 (37 files) |
| `Button` | `AppliedObjectStyle="ObjectStyle/$ID/[None]"` | DOM 8 to 13 (40 files) |
| `MultiStateObject` | `InitiallyHidden="false"` and page item values | DOM 8 to 13 (16 files) |
The page item values are those also kept for groups: the gradient
angles and highlights, `LocalDisplaySetting`, the layout constraints and
the change counts, which the converter writes from the INDD where it has
them. `Button` `PrintableInPdf` is on 216 of 284 buttons: the later
versions have too few files to keep it. Check boxes, radio buttons,
text boxes, combo boxes and signature fields are in fewer than 10 files
each, so no value of theirs is kept; their constant flags (`ReadOnly`,
`PrintableInPdf` and others) are not written.
### Spreads, pages and layers
| Element | Elements | Values kept |
|---|---|---|
| `Spread` | 11,914 | `PageTransitionDuration="Medium"`, `ShowMasterItems="true"`, `FlattenerOverride="Default"` from DOM 7; `SpreadHidden="false"` from 19 |
| `FlattenerPreference` of spreads | 11,914 | `ClipComplexRegions`, `ConvertAllStrokesToOutlines`, `ConvertAllTextToOutlines` (`false`) and `RasterVectorBalance` 50 from DOM 7 |
| `MasterSpread` | 2,461 | `OverriddenPageItemProps=""` from DOM 7 |
| `Page` | 22,877 | `AppliedTrapPreset="TrapPreset/$ID/kDefaultTrapStyleName"` from DOM 7; `SnapshotBlendingMode="IgnoreLayoutSnapshots"`, `OptionalPage="false"` from 8 |
| `Layer` | 2,723 | `ShowGuides` and `Expendable` (`true`) from DOM 7 |
`Spread` `PageTransitionType` and `PageTransitionDirection` are left
out: spreads of 6 files have page transitions.
`Page` `GridStartingPoint` is left out: 28 pages of DOM 18 files have
another value than `TopOutside`.
Every spread has one `FlattenerPreference`, so the converter writes the
element on every spread. For a spread without the flattener chunk
(`objects.md`, flattener settings) it also writes
`LineArtAndTextResolution` and `GradientAndMeshResolution`: 300 and
150, or 400 and 400 after a session of a Japanese or Chinese edition,
by the language code of the save history (`objects.md`, flattener
settings). The other attributes of these elements come
from the INDD (`objects.md`).
### Document settings in designmap.xml
These elements are children of `Document` without `Self`. The tool keeps
an element when every IDML from some version on has it, with the values
all of them have; the converter writes it in the order of the IDML files.
| Element | From DOM | Values kept | Left out (vary) |
|---|---|---|---|
| `ConditionalTextPreference` | 7 | both | |
| `EndnoteOption` | 13 | 9 | `EndnoteTitle`, `EndnoteSeparatorText`, the marker and text styles, `EndnoteMarkerPositioning` |
| `TextFrameFootnoteOptionsObject` | 12 | all 4 | |
| `LinkedStoryOption` | 8 | all 4 | |
| `LinkedPageItemOption` | 8 | all 7 | |
| `WatermarkPreference` | 7 | 11 | the font family, style and colour |
| `TaggedPDFPreference` | 8 | (element only) | `StructureOrder` |
| `AdjustLayoutPreference` | 14 | 4 | `EnableAdjustLayout`, `EnableAutoAdjustMargins`, `AllowFontSizeAndLeadingAdjustment` |
| `HTMLFXLExportPreference` | 10.1 | both | |
| `PublishExportPreference` | 11 | 7 | `ImageExportResolution`, `PublishPdf`, `CoverPage`, `PublishDescription`, `PublishFileName`, `PublishPageRange` |
| `Html5ExportPreference` | 21.1 | both | |
`HTMLFXLExportPreference` (`EpubPageRange=""`,
`EpubPageRangeFormat="ExportAllPages"`) is in every IDML from DOM 10.1
(all 1,556 distinct corpus files of DOM 10.1 and later) and in none of
DOM 10.0 (10 files) or earlier. The converter writes it by the DOM
version it writes (10.1 for files of version 10 last saved by 10.1 or
later). Over the trustworthy pairs it reproduces the element in 1,139
of 1,139 documents.
`Html5ExportPreference` (`TextExportFormat="HtmlTag"`,
`CopyFonts="false"`) is in every IDML from DOM 21.1, directly after
`PublishExportPreference`: 59 of 59 distinct corpus files of DOM 21.1 to
21.5. No file of DOM 21.0 or earlier has it (1,397 files). The values
never vary. The converter writes it by the DOM version it writes.
The values left out here are read from the INDD or follow the rules of
`preferences.md` (adjust layout; EPUB, HTML and Publish Online export;
values of the exporting edition). The converter writes
`TaggedPDFPreference` from version 7.5, which the per-major blocks
cannot express.
### DOM version
Every package part has the `DOMVersion` of the application that
exported the IDML. Several releases keep the DOM version of an earlier
one. Over the 1,460 pairs of the corpus of 2026-10, by the version of
the last session of the save history (`objects.md`, save history):
| Last session | `DOMVersion` |
|---|---|
| 9.1, 9.2 | 9.0 |
| 11.1 | 11.0 |
| 14.3 | 14.0 |
| 16.3, 16.4 | 16.2 |
| 17.1 to 17.4 | 17.0 |
| 18.1 to 18.4 | 18.0 |
| 19.1, 19.2 | 19.0 |
| 20.1 | 20.0 |
| 20.5 | 20.4 |
| every other version seen (7.0 to 21.5) | its major and minor version |
The converter writes this value, from the header's version where the
save history has none or names another major version. It matches 1,164
of 1,251 trustworthy pairs (the header's major version with `.0`
matched 668). The others are files that a later release exported
without saving them: 68 sessions of 10.1 whose IDML has 10.2, 16 of
13.0 with 13.1, and 3 more; their IDML `product` names that release.
This is a rule of the exporting edition (`preferences.md`, values of
the exporting edition).
The later release leaves no trace in the INDD. Over all 1,462 pairs, 67
of the 68 sessions of 10.1 and all 16 of 13.0 are on platform 3 (the
second u16 of the save history record; `objects.md`, save history), and
their IDML has the same `xmpMM:InstanceID` as the INDD. But platform 3
does not decide the version: of the 68 platform-3 sessions of 10.1 in
these pairs, one has an IDML of 10.1 (`product` `10.1(70)`), and 2 of
the 18 platform-3 sessions of 13.0 have one of 13.0. For 13.0 the
other fields of the record (the build, the two u16 not identified) are
the same in both groups; for 10.1 the second u16 not identified is 2 in
the one exception and 1 in the 67, a difference of one document. The
converter writes the version of the last session.
`Assignment` (1,495 elements, one per file): `UserName="$ID/"`,
`ExportOptions="AssignedSpreads"`, `IncludeLinksWhenPackage="true"`,
`FilePath="$ID/"` and `FrameColor` `Nothing`, from DOM 7.
### Language quotes
A language object stores its quotes only in chunk 0x2D26, which 34
language objects of the corpus have (`objects.md`, languages); the
converter writes those. For the others, for each language name the tool
keeps `SingleQuotes` and `DoubleQuotes` when every IDML `Language`
element with that name has the same value, in at least 3 files (a
`Keyed` block of the values file): 64 languages.
The tool reads IDML only, so it counts the languages with chunk 0x2D26
too. Over the 3,139 IDML languages of the corpus pairs matched with an
INDD language, only Romanian differs because of them: every Romanian
language without the chunk has `‚’` and `„”` (21 of 21 files), and the
one with the chunk `‘’` and `»«`. The converter writes these quotes for
Romanian without the chunk. Three names differ without the chunk too,
and are left out: Japanese (`''` and `""` in 162 files, `‘’` and `“”`
in 2), Korean (457 and 7) and Hebrew (74 and 1, `‘’` and `“”`). No
stored value tells the exceptions apart; they follow the dictionary
preferences of the exporting computer.
These exceptions follow no stored value. The converter writes the
common value, `''` and `""`, for Japanese, Korean and Hebrew languages
without the chunk as a default ([Defaults](#defaults)).
Colours are keyed by `Model`: every spot colour has
`SpotInkAliasSpotColorReference="n"` (5,182 of 5,182 in the 1,689
distinct corpus IDML files outside the privately held samples, DOM 8 to
21), and no process (46,211) or registration (1,685) colour has the
attribute. No ink of the corpus has an alias. The converter writes it
after `ColorOverride` on spot colours: 5,090 of 5,090 values of the
trustworthy pairs.
Pasted smooth shades are keyed the same way by `ContentsType`: every
`ConstantShade` (and every `AxialShade`) has `ContentsVersion="0"`,
`SpotColorList=""`, `ContentsEncoding="Ascii64Encoding"`,
`ColorEditable` and `ColorRemovable` `true`, `Visible="false"` and
`SwatchCreatorID="7937"`; constant shades also
`ContentsMatrix="1 0 0 1 0 0"`.
### Paragraph and character styles
The styles other than the root styles (8,603 paragraph and 3,666
character styles in the IDML files):
| Values kept | Styles | Versions |
|---|---|---|
| `PreviewColor` `Nothing` | paragraph | 7 on |
| `EpubAriaRole=""` | paragraph and character | 21 on |
| `IncludeClass="true"` | character | 13 on |
Character styles' `PreviewColor` and `ExtendedKeyboardShortcut` are left
out: a few styles have other values.
TOC styles (1,556 in the IDML files) all have `RunIn="false"` and
`IncludeHidden="false"`. `SetStoryDirection` varies and is read from
the INDD (`objects.md`, table of contents styles).
`SplitDocument`, `EmitCss` and `IncludeClass` are read from the INDD
(`objects.md`, styles, export settings), as are keyboard shortcuts.
Table and cell styles other than the root styles (1,587 and 138 in the
IDML files) all have `KeyboardShortcut="0 0"` (cell styles from DOM 8,
with 44 files) and `ExtendedKeyboardShortcut="0 0 0"` from DOM 15; the
converter writes them. `Imported` and `StyleUniqueId` come from the INDD
(`objects.md`, styles).
### Sections
Every `Section` of DOM 8 (96 sections in the corpus IDML files) has
`Pagination="AutoPaginate"` and `PaginationMaster="n"`, after
`AlternateLayout`; no section of another DOM version has them. The tool
keeps them for DOM 8 (`Values` block of version 8 to 8), and the
converter writes them there: 85 of 85 values each in the trustworthy
pairs.
### Swatches
| Element | Values kept |
|---|---|
| `Tint` | `ColorOverride="Normal"`, `ColorEditable`, `ColorRemovable`, `Visible` (`true`) and `SwatchCreatorID="7937"` from DOM 8 (270 tints in 142 files); `ConvertToHsb="false"` from 17 |
| `Gradient` | `SwatchCreatorID="7937"` (and the flags, which the converter reads) from DOM 7 |
| `Swatch` (`None`) | `SwatchCreatorID="7937"` from DOM 7 |
Colours have their creator and alternate colour in the INDD
(`objects.md`, colours).
### Trap presets
All 1,495 IDML files list the same two `TrapPreset` elements at the end of
`Resources/Styles.xml`, with the same attributes: `$ID/k[No Trap
Preset]` and `$ID/kDefaultTrapStyleName`, which every page applies. The
converter writes the list (a `List` block of the values file). One DOM
12 file has a third preset, named by the user, after these two. Its INDD
object is not decoded, so the tool leaves presets with such names out of
the list.
### Values written where the converter writes the attribute
Some attributes are only on some elements; IDML writes them where a
frame's value differs from its object style, or from some version on.
For these the tool keeps a value when every element that has the
attribute has the same value (`WhenWritten` blocks). The converter
writes them on every text frame of those versions:
| `TextFramePreference` values | Versions |
|---|---|
| `VerticalThreshold="0"` | 7 on |
| `UseFlexibleColumnWidth="false"` | 8 on |
| `FootnotesEnableOverrides`, `FootnotesSpanAcrossColumns` (`false`) | 13 on |
| `ColumnRuleOffset`, `ColumnRuleTopInset`, `ColumnRuleBottomInset` (`0`), `ColumnRuleInsetChainOverride="true"`, `ColumnRuleStrokeTint="100"`, `ColumnRuleStrokeType="StrokeStyle/$ID/Solid"`, `ColumnRuleOverprintOverride="false"` | 15 on |
The first version of the column rule and footnote values is also where
the converter starts writing the column rule and footnote values it
reads from the INDD (`objects.md`, text frame preferences).
### Export options of page items
`ObjectExportOption` of page items has different attributes in different
INDD versions, major and minor. Over the 92,409 page items of the
trustworthy pairs there is no exception inside a version:
| INDD version | Attributes in addition to the common set |
|---|---|
| 7 | no `ObjectExportOption` |
| 8.0–9.1 | `CustomImageConversion="false"`, `CustomImageSizeOption="SizeRelativeToPageWidth"` |
| 9.2 | also `UseOriginalImage="false"` |
| 10.0 | `EpubType="$ID/"`, `UseExistingImage="false"`, `CustomHeightType="DefaultHeight"`, `CustomHeight="$ID/"`, `CustomWidthType="DefaultWidth"`, `CustomWidth="$ID/"`, `CustomImageConversion="false"`, `UseOriginalImage="false"` |
| 10.1 on | `EpubType="$ID/"`, `SizeType="DefaultSize"`, `CustomSize="$ID/"`, `PreserveAppearanceFromLayout="PreserveAppearanceDefault"` |
| 21.0 on | also `EpubAriaRole="$ID/"` |
| 21.1 on | also `EpubAriaLabel="$ID/"`, `EpubAriaLabelSourceType="AutomaticARIALabel"` |
| 21.4 on | also `AIGeneratedAltText`, `AltTextGenerationError` and `AltTextCropSyncRect`, read from chunks 0x1E260–0x1E262 (`objects.md`, generated alternative text; `false`, `false` and empty without them) |
The common set, on every page item from version 8 on: the alternative
text and tagging values (`AltTextSourceType`, `ActualTextSourceType`,
`CustomAltText`, `CustomActualText`, `ApplyTagType`, read from chunk
0x1E206, `objects.md`), `ImageConversionType="JPEG"`,
`ImageExportResolution="Ppi300"`, `GIFOptionsPalette="AdaptivePalette"`,
`GIFOptionsInterlaced="true"`, `JPEGOptionsQuality="High"`,
`JPEGOptionsFormat="BaselineEncoding"`, `ImageAlignment="AlignLeft"`,
`ImageSpaceBefore="0"`, `ImageSpaceAfter="0"`,
`UseImagePageBreak="false"`, `ImagePageBreak="PageBreakBefore"`,
`CustomImageAlignment="false"`, `SpaceUnit="CssPixel"`,
`CustomLayout="false"`, `CustomLayoutType="AlignmentAndSpacing"`, and
the `Properties` children `AltMetadataProperty` and
`ActualMetadataProperty` (their values also from chunk 0x1E206). These
are constant in all 93,701 elements except `ImageAlignment` (3
`AlignCenter`) and `SizeType` (3 `RelativeToTextFlow`), all in the same 3
items of one document; their INDD field is not identified.
Object styles, `[None]` included, have `ObjectExportOption` from version
9 on (all 1,882 styles of those versions), with the common set (all
values constant) and the same version-dependent attributes, except that
21.4 on adds only `AltTextCropSyncRect=""`.
The converter writes these values by the version of the INDD file. It
leaves out `CustomImageSizeOption`: the IDML schema the output is
checked against does not allow that value. The `ObjectExportOption`
blocks of `element_values.xml`, `root_values.xml` and
`object_style_values.xml` are not used, because those files are keyed
by major version only.
Every `InCopyExportOption` of a rectangle, oval or polygon in the 1,495
corpus IDML files has `IncludeGraphicProxies="true"` and
`IncludeAllResources="false"` (`element_values.xml`; ovals from DOM 8,
as no DOM 7 file has one). The converter writes the element with these
values on those items.
## Column direction of pages
The `ColumnDirection` of pages is read from the INDD (`objects.md`,
page settings), and that of `MarginPreference` and `DocumentPreference`
too (`preferences.md`, margins and columns of new pages).
## Font platform name
`PlatformName` is `$ID/` in every `Font` element of the corpus IDML
files except the fonts of missing-font records, where it is read from
the record (`fonts.md`, missing fonts). The converter writes `$ID/` on
every other font.
## Number format
IDML writes a number as the shortest decimal that reads back as the same
64-bit value. When two decimals of that length read back as the value,
IDML takes the one nearest to the exact binary value, and of two equally
near (the value lies exactly halfway, common for values that came from
32-bit floats) the one with the even last digit. For example the value
150.235992431640625 is written `150.23599243164062`, not `…063`.
Numbers below 1e-4 are written with an exponent of at least two digits
(`5.684341886080802e-14`, `1.8897456811828306e-05`); all others are
written in plain notation.
Evidence: of the 1,090,937 distinct numeric texts in the attributes of
the 654 reference IDMLs of the corpus before 2026-10, the rule gives the
same text for all but 67, which are text values rather than numbers
(`DOMVersion="17.0"`, `2.000`, `0.80`). Rust's shortest form differs on
7,674 of them: ties written with the odd digit, and small numbers
written without an exponent. The INDD values of `GraphicBounds` (chunk
0x1633), written this way, equal the IDML text in all 1,774 PDF, 407 EPS
and 233 SVG graphics of the 803 pairs (`compare.py` compares
`Properties` children as text). The converter writes every number this
way.
## Preferences
`Resources/Preferences.xml` of every corpus IDML has the same 41
top-level elements (`TextDefault`, `TextPreference`,
`TextFramePreference`, `PageItemDefault`, `StoryPreference`,
`FootnoteOption`, `TransparencyDefaultContainerObject` and others; the
DOM 7 file lacks `EPubFixedLayoutExportPreference`). `tools/root_values.py`
collects each attribute, `Properties` child and child element attribute
of these elements with the same rule as for the root styles, and writes
the kept values to `src/idml/preference_values.xml`. The converter writes
those elements in the order the IDML files list them.
| Values | Same in | Written for version |
|---|---|---|
| 697 | 1,450 of 1,450 files | all |
| 73, 2, 14, 1, 1, 21, 4, 10 | all files with DOM 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15 or later | from that version |
| 2 | 255 of 255 files with DOM 18 or later | 18 and later |
| 19 | 94 of 94 files with DOM 20 or later | 20 and later |
For example `TextDefault` keeps 140 of its 318 values,
`TransparencyDefaultContainerObject` all 352 and `TextFramePreference`
29 of 34.
**Left out:**
- 593 values that vary between files, for example the page size,
margins and grid settings, 178 values of `TextDefault` (among them the
font and point size, `KeepFirstLines` and `KeepLastLines`) and 30 of
`TextPreference`. Most of these differ in one to five documents; the
converter does not read them from the INDD yet.
- The document setup the converter reads from the INDD (`objects.md`):
`PageHeight`, `PageWidth`, `FacingPages`, `Intent`, `PageBinding` and
the four bleed offsets of `DocumentPreference`. The converter writes its own values
for these and adds the observed values for the rest of the element.
`ViewPreference` gets the `RulerOrigin` read from the INDD
(`preferences.md`).
- `AppliedGridObjectStyle` of `PageItemDefault`, which names a style
other than a root style that the package need not contain.
- Values first seen in a later version that fewer than 10 files show.
`tools/element_values.py` also collects the preference elements from all
1,495 IDML files of the corpus (paths `Preferences/<tag>` in
`src/idml/element_values.xml`), with its rule for other elements (per
range of DOM versions, at least 10 files). The converter adds these
values where `preference_values.xml` has none. They add, for example,
the auto-sizing values of `TextFramePreference` for DOM 8 to 11 and the
values of `EPubExportPreference` and `HTMLExportPreference` that all
files from DOM 8 on have. `PageItemDefault` values that name an object
style are written only when the package has that style.
**Values kept despite unpaired files.** `XMLImportPreference`
`AllowTransform="false"`, `ImportCALSTables="true"`,
`ImportTextIntoTables="true"`, `ImportToSelected="true"`,
`RemoveUnmatchedExisting="false"`, `RepeatTextElements="true"` and
`DictionaryPreference` `MergeUserDictionary="false"` are the same in all
803 pairs of the corpus before 2026-10. Two IDML files of the 827 it had differ: one in the six
`XMLImportPreference` values, one in `MergeUserDictionary`. Both were
exported by an earlier version than their INDD was last saved with, so
they are not pairs, and the INDD cannot show which field holds the
value. The values are probably stored in the INDD; with no pair that
varies, the field cannot be found. `element_values.py` keeps these
values from the other files (`LATER_INDD_EXCEPTIONS`).
**DOM 7.** DOM 7 references have no `EPubExportPreference` and no
`HTMLExportPreference` (7 of 7 trustworthy pairs before 2026-10;
`preference_values.xml` lists their values from DOM 8). The converter
leaves both out before DOM 8.
Some of these values are probably stored in the INDD and may differ in a
document outside the corpus; none of them is read from the INDD yet. A
sample typeset vertically shows this: two 2-byte fields of the
preferences object (chunks 0xCD14 and 0xCD1C) are 1 there and 0 in all
250 distinct little-endian public files. The print PDF cannot show which preference each
field holds, so they are not mapped.
## Defaults
A **default** is a value the converter writes although no INDD field
holds it and a few reference IDML files have another value. The
converter writes it because it is the value of nearly every reference,
and a missing attribute leaves a consumer to its own default, which can
differ. Nothing stored tells the exceptions apart. Counts are over the
1,252 trustworthy pairs (`docs/measurement.md`), for the versions given.
| Element | Attribute | Value | DOM versions | Trustworthy references with the value |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| `PrintPreference` | `TilingType` | `Auto` | all | 1,251 of 1,252 (1 `AutoJustified`) |
| `TextPreference` | `HighlightKeeps` | `false` | all | 1,248 of 1,252 |
| `TextPreference` | `HighlightSubstitutedFonts` | `true` | all | 1,249 of 1,252 |
| `ViewPreference` | `GuideSnaptoZone` | `4` | all | 1,247 of 1,252 (5 `2`) |
| `ViewPreference` | `ShowNotes` | `true` | all | 1,233 of 1,252 |
| `XMLExportPreference` | `ViewAfterExport` | `false` | all | 1,251 of 1,252 |
| `DocumentPreference` | `SpreadHiddenVisibility` | `false` | 20.0 on | 75 of 76 |
| `Document` | `AppliedMathMLFontSize` | `10` | 20.0 on | 75 of 76 (1 `16`, DOM 20.2) |
| `Article` | `ArticleExportStatus` | `true` | all | 31 of 31 articles in 13 pairs; no other value in 3,557 corpus IDML files |
| `MatchParagraphStylePreference` (running header) whose settings parse with *c* 0 or 1 | `DeleteEndPunctuation` | `false` | all | 1,288 of 1,288; no other value in 3,568 corpus IDML elements (`text-variables.md`, settings) |
| `Language` named Korean, Japanese or Hebrew, without chunk 0x2D26 | `SingleQuotes`, `DoubleQuotes` | `''`, `""` | all | Korean 448 of 455, Japanese 128 of 130, Hebrew 65 of 66 languages |
No reference before DOM 20.0 has `SpreadHiddenVisibility` or
`AppliedMathMLFontSize`, and every one from 20.0 has both. For
`ArticleExportStatus` no reference has another value, so a stored field
cannot be told apart (`objects.md`, articles). The quotes of the three languages vary with the dictionary
preferences of the exporting computer (language quotes, above).
`Document` `UntitledDocumentCount` is not written. Every DOM 12
reference has it (directly after `StoryList`, `1` in 68 of 72), and no
other. No stored field follows it; it most likely depends on the session
of the exporting InDesign. The published IDML schema does not allow it,
so writing it would make the package fail validation.
Defaults of other elements are documented with their objects:
- Movies and sounds: `objects.md`, [movies and
sounds](objects.md#movies-and-sounds-classes-0x14801-and-0x14f01),
"Values without a stored field".
- Button behaviours: `objects.md`, [button
behaviours](objects.md#button-behaviours), "Values with no stored
field".
- Timing lists, motion presets and animation settings: `objects.md`,
[values without a stored
field](objects.md#values-without-a-stored-field).
- Linked story options (three attributes, 30 of 30 stories), Word import
options (8 items, 39 of 39 stories) and Excel import options (6 items,
9 of 9 stories): `objects.md`, [story links and placed
text](objects.md#story-links-and-placed-text). No reference has
another value.